יום ראשון, 4 בנובמבר 2012


Peace divide

By JPOST EDITORIAL
11/04/2012 20:55

The capacity to make peace depends on changing perceptions – including the national narratives we tell ourselves and our peoples. The fallout from Abbas’s Channel 2 interview is yet another dismal indicator that the Palestinian people have yet to be prepared by their leadership for such a change.

PA President Mahmoud Abbas on Channel 2PHOTO: SCREENSHOT
In an interview last week with Channel 2’s Udi Segal, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas presented a surprisingly moderate stance vis-à-vis Palestinians’ “right of return.”

Though he clarified that the issue would have to be settled in negotiations, Abbas admitted that he personally had no “right” to return permanently to his birthplace in Safed.

“Palestine now for me is the [June 4], 1967, borders, with east Jerusalem as its capital,” he said. “This is now and forever.... This is Palestine for me. I am [a] refugee, but I am living in Ramallah.”

Abbas even went on to reject references in official Palestinian television to places such as Acre, Ramle and Jaffa – all cities well within sovereign Israel – as “Palestine,” and added, “I believe that [the] the West Bank and Gaza is Palestine and the other parts [are] Israel.”

Abbas’s comments for Channel 2 were reminiscent of statements the PA president purportedly made during negotiations in 2008 with then-prime minister Ehud Olmert and then-foreign minister Tzipi Livni.

According to the “PaliLeaks” documents apparently leaked by the Palestinian Negotiation Support Unit to Al Jazeera andThe Guardian and made public in January 2011, Abbas admitted that “on numbers of refugees, it is illogical to ask Israel to take 5 million, or even 1 million – that would mean the end of Israel.”

Both the Channel 2 interview and the PaliLeaks documents seemed to reveal a refreshing pragmatism and willingness to compromise among the Palestinian leadership.

One of the major obstacles to peace – the issue of the Palestinian insistence on the “right of return” for millions of “refugees” – appeared to be eminently soluble.

Unfortunately, as in the aftermath of the PaliLeaks revelations, high-ranking Palestinian officials rushed to “clarify” Abbas’s comments, revealing once again the yawning divide that continues to separate our two peoples.

Rather than using Abbas’s comments on the “right of return” as an opportunity to show the world that Palestinians are willing to show flexibility on a maximalist demand that would mean the end of Israel as a state with a Jewish majority, the official PA reaction was the complete opposite.

Nabil Abu Rudaineh, a spokesman for Abbas, responding to sharp criticism of the PA president on the Palestinian street, reiterated Palestinian intransigence on the refugee issue.

“The position of the Palestinian leadership remains fixed,” Abu Rudaineh said. “The refugees and the right of return are among the final-status issues that will be negotiated with the Israelis.” He went on to say that Abbas’s interview was nothing more than a tactical move aimed at “affecting Israeli public opinion.”

Even if we are to take Abbas’s comments at face value and believe that he and others in the PA are responsible leaders sincerely interested in working toward a sovereign Palestinian state living in peace alongside the Jewish state of Israel, this is not enough. Abbas is paying for his own and his leadership’s insistence on saying one thing in public and something else altogether behind closed doors or in an interview aimed at the Israel public.

When speaking to the Palestinians, the Abbas-led PA has consistently marginalized or outright denied the Jewish people’s historic, religious and cultural ties to the Land of Israel. It has glorified terrorists who have massacred Israelis, while depicting the Jews of Israel as evil and rapacious.

Given the narrative they are fed by their leaders, why would the Palestinian people agree to compromise with an ostensibly illegitimate Zionist entity on the refugee issue? Why would they be willing to give up a “right of return” that has become an integral part of Palestinian identity? Abbas and other Palestinian leaders could and should have worked to prepare their people for peace with Israel.

They could and should have adjusted the public messages to the Palestinian people to reflect the types of sane and realistic statements made to Channel 2 or behind closed doors in negotiations with Israel.

The capacity to make peace depends on changing perceptions – including the national narratives we tell ourselves and our peoples. The fallout from Abbas’s Channel 2 interview is yet another dismal indicator that the Palestinian people have yet to be prepared by their leadership for such a change.

יום שלישי, 30 באוקטובר 2012


Fischer's warning

By JPOST EDITORIAL
10/30/2012 23:51

Bank of Israel chief lowered the interest rate in order help rejuvenate the slowing economy.


It is reassuring to have a world-class economist at the helm of the Bank of Israel. Just knowing that Stanley Fischer – a former chief economist of the World Bank and former professor at MIT whose students included the current chairman of the US Federal Reserve, Ben Bernanke – is responsible for our monetary policy can have a calming effect on the economy as we approach turbulent times.

When Fischer expresses concern about a particular aspect of our economy, political leaders should sit up and pay attention. The Bank of Israel governor is, apparently, unhappy with our overheated housing market.

In a move billed as nothing short of “dramatic,” Fischer ordered the banks to lower the loan-tovalue (LTV) ratio to 50 percent for mortgages provided to house purchasers who intend their purchase to be an investment – including foreign investors. Mortgages for a first house will be limited to a LTV ratio of 75%.

The move is designed to counter the effect of yet another prime interest rate cut from 2.25% to 2%.

Fischer lowered the interest rate in order help rejuvenate the slowing economy.

However, lower interest rates also tend to push investors out of solid investments such as government bonds or savings plans offered by banks and to encourage them to look for alternative “solid” investments such as the housing market.

Rent yields pay off the low interest; capital gains from rising real estate prices (housing prices are up 2.9% in the past six months) provide the investor with easy profits.

Of the 20% of Israelis who hold mortgages, it is estimated that 9% are investors while only 3% are those who own only one home. About a quarter of all house purchases are made by investors.

Fischer is concerned that banks are overly exposed to the housing market. Some 40% of banks’ credit is extended to building contractors and home owners. A sudden decrease in housing prices could result in an economic crisis similar to the US subprime mortgage crisis of the late 2000s.

By restricting the LTV ration to just 50%, Fischer hopes to reduce banks’ exposure and slow the sharp rise in housing prices by lowering demand for houses.

Still, Fischer’s ability to fight rising housing prices is limited. Restricting the LTV ratio might make it more difficult for investors to buy houses.

But as long as investors recognize that there is a severe shortage of housing in Israel they will have an incentive to invest in the housing market.

Fertility rates are higher in Israel than anywhere in the Western world and they have been for decades. Every year tens of thousands of young families add to the demand for housing. In parallel, the Israel Lands Authority, which controls the supply of land for housing, is notoriously inefficient and burdened by red tape. As a result, the construction process is dragged out and land prices remain high.

The only way to truly fight housing prices is by focusing not on demand, but on supply. Currently, the number of houses constructed every year cannot keep up with demand. More new housing – for sale and for rent – needs to be provided. In parallel, the zoning process for housing needs to be made more efficient, while at the same time not compromising the necessary oversight that prevents damage to the environment or to historical sites. Replacing old, low-story buildings in city centers with high-rises should be encouraged as a way of limiting to a minimum building in open green areas.

Only the government, which is currently focused on elections, can direct all these changes. Voters must demand that a solution to the housing shortage be a central issue in the election campaigns of all the major political parties.

The next government must commit itself to grappling with the housing shortage. We are lucky to have a man as talented as Fischer heading the Bank of Israel. But there is only so much one man can do.

יום שני, 29 באוקטובר 2012


Connecting to the South

By JPOST EDITORIAL
10/29/2012 23:43

Regardless of the strategy or strategies implemented by the government, it is imperative that the residents of the South know that they have not been abandoned.


Since the latest escalation in southern Israel began a little over a week ago, hundreds of mortar shells and rockets have been fired at cities and towns there. Hamas and the myriad Salafist and jihadist organizations operating inside Gaza that are launching their ballistic attacks on Israel have disrupted the lives of hundreds of thousands of innocent men, women and children in places like Sderot, Kibbutz Nirim and Beersheba.

Schools have been closed down, families have been forced to spend hours locked up in bomb shelters and the regular pace of life has been underscored by the constant fear of the next mortar shell or rocket falling from the sky.

Israel’s options for stopping the barrage of fire from Gaza are limited. Diplomatically, Jerusalem might succeed – with American help – in putting pressure on Cairo to use its influence with Hamas to stop the shooting. Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi might be interested in preventing further escalation between Israel and Hamas-controlled Gaza in order to avoid getting dragged into a direct conflict with Jerusalem and Washington.

But even if Morsi agrees to attempt to put pressure on the Hamas leadership, it is not at all clear that Hamas is fully capable of bringing about a cease-fire.

Firstly, many of the terrorist groups operating inside Gaza are not fully under Hamas’s control. Secondly, in the world of fundamentalist Islamic politics that aggrandizes death and destruction, Hamas does not want to be perceived as conciliatory and weak vis-à-vis Israel.

Israel’s military options are likewise limited. It could continue the present tactic of launching either a preemptive attack or retaliation – either by air or on the ground – for each attempt by Hamas or other terrorist organizations to strike against Israel. Our armed forces could supplement this ongoing military response with targeted killings directed at the upper echelon of the various terrorist organizations operating in Gaza.

The IDF could also initiate a escalation from the air, the sea and the ground aimed at drawing out and eliminating additional terrorists operating in Gaza and destroying their infrastructure. Though such an initiated escalation could strengthen Israel’s deterrence, it could also lead to a full-fledged war, complete with unintended civilian casualties and international condemnation.

However, in the short run, none of these tactics will enable Israelis living in the South to return to normalcy and end the terror of living under the constant threat of rockets and mortar fire. In fact, an initiated escalation or stepping up targeted killings would only result in an increased barrage of fire from Gaza – at least in the short-term – and more suffering for the South’s residents.

Regardless of the strategy or strategies implemented by the government, it is imperative that the residents of the South know that they have not been abandoned.

Fellow Israeli citizens living in Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, Haifa and other locations that are – for the time being – safely out of range of the mortar shells and rockets shot from Gaza should show their solidarity with the South’s residents.

The cabinet, which on Sunday approved a three-year, NIS 270 million plan for the building of 1,700 bomb shelters in towns and cities located three to seven kilometers from the border with Gaza, should also consider holding one of its upcoming weekly meetings in the South.

Radio and television news programs should make an effort to broadcast from the South. And if, due to the security risk, it is too much to ask for more fortunate Israelis to actually visit the South, schools, youth groups, synagogues and even sports clubs should make an effort to remember the plight of their brothers and sisters.

Above all, we must avoid a situation in which large segments of society go about their business as though all is well. We must not be disconnected from what is happening in the South.

יום ראשון, 28 באוקטובר 2012


Stability in unity

By JPOST EDITORIAL
10/28/2012 21:15

Large right-of-center list may bring political stability.


Sharp criticism was not long in coming after Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Avigdor Liberman’s surprise announcement that the Likud and Yisrael Beytenuwould run on a join list in the elections for the 19th Knesset.

Much of the criticism seemed to emanate more from a desire to defend narrow personal interests than a genuine concern for the greater good of the nation’s political stability.

Some Likud ministers, Knesset members and would-be Knesset members have expressed fear that the joint Likud-Yisrael Beytenu list, rather than producing more seats than the two parties’ current 42 (Likud 27; Yisrael Beytenu 15), will lead to a fall in their Knesset representation.

Likud MKs and ministers fighting for a Knesset seat are afraid that the merger could jeopardize their place on the Likud candidates list. Likud ministers with a strong support base in Likud’s central committee, such as Gideon Sa’ar, Israel Katz and Silvan Shalom, who expected to rank high on the party’s list, are understandably unhappy with the prospect of seeing their places taken by Yisrael Beytenu parliamentarians chosen by an internal committee controlled by Liberman.

Another claim, one that smacks of ethnic chauvinism, is that the merger, which will bring to the joint list a large proportion of voters and politicians who are immigrants from the former Soviet Union, will scare away the Mizrahim – Israelis whose families immigrated to Israel from Muslim countries in the Middle East, who make up a large part of the Likud’s voters.

However, if the deal is analyzed with the interests of the nation’s political system in mind, its pluses clearly outweigh its minuses.

The most obvious benefit is the creation of a single, large right-wing party with the potential to bring more stability to our political system. Parties left-of-center might also form a united list in response to the Likud-Yisrael Beytenu move.

Ideally, two large parties – one on the Left and one on the Right – will represent the two mainstream positions on cardinal issues such as security and socio-economics.

Smaller parties – particularly national-religious and haredi factions – would be less able to take advantage of our splintered political system to exert influence that far exceeds their size.

Over the past few decades, the size of the two largest political parties – traditionally Labor and the Likud – has steadily decreased due to the establishment of various short-lived centrist parties. Until 1996, the two largest parties consistently held a total of more than 70 Knesset seats.

Since 1999, the two largest parties have garnered less than half the Knesset seats. This has hurt what political scientists call governance or governability – the ability of governments to make decisions and to follow through on them.

A 2005 study by Doron Navot and Eli Reches found that 70 percent of government decisions – on subjects ranging from public housing to privatization of the sea ports, from reforms in the Israel Electric Corporation to the construction of a light rail system in Tel Aviv – are left unimplemented.

And as Amnon Rubinstein and Adam Wolfson wrote in their book Absence of Government: How to Rectify the System, sometimes these ignored government decisions result in disaster. Our sorrowfully inadequate firefighting capabilities – shockingly revealed in the 2010 Mount Carmel forest fire disaster – were the direct result of consecutive government decisions calling for the revamping of our firefighting services remaining unimplemented.

Undoubtedly, election reforms such as the raising of the threshold for a political party to get elected to the Knesset from just 2% of the vote and the institution of regional elections for some seats – and perhaps increasing the total number of MKs – would go a long way toward improving political stability and politicians’ accountability.

However, the formation of a large right-of-center list – which might inspire the left-of-center parties to do the same – could bring much-needed political stability and a higher level of governance to our political system.

יום שלישי, 17 באפריל 2012

Holocaust images

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=266456

This year, as in previous years ahead of Holocaust Remembrance Day, the media have focused heavily on the severe poverty and substandard living conditions of many Holocaust survivors.

Newspapers, radio, TV and the Internet have featured profiles of Holocaust survivors living in rundown flats that lack basic utilities.

Survivors who were on the receiving end of the lethal hatred that swept across Europe are disappearing, and many of those who remain are in desperate need of aid. Over the past year alone, about 12,000 Holocaust survivors have passed away – more than one every hour – according to data published this week by the Foundation for the Benefit of Holocaust Victims in Israel based on a survey carried out by the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee-affiliated Myers-JDC-Brookdale Institute. If in 1961, during the trial of Adolf Eichmann, the 500,000 survivors living here made up about 25 percent of the population, today there are just 198,000, about 2.5% of the population.

Probably the most infuriating pieces of data from that same Myers-JDC-Brookdale Institute report – based on a survey of 52,500 survivors supported by the foundation – is that 5% complained they did not have enough to eat. In Israel of all places, it is essential that everything be done to ensure that no Holocaust survivor goes hungry or is left without proper medical care.

However, the annual publicity campaigns that sweep the nation at this time of year with the implicit message that not enough is being done for Holocaust survivors – and that the State of Israel is to blame – project a distorted picture of reality. Over the past year the government has increased the amount of annual aid to Holocaust survivors by NIS 6 million to NIS 206m. In addition, the Conference for Material Claims Against Germany and various charities also contribute to the welfare of the survivors.

One cannot help but wonder whether these campaigns are motivated by the desire on the part of various charity organizations to exploit Holocaust Remembrance Day as an opportunity to fund-raise not just for the survivors but also to perpetuate expensive administrative infrastructures that employ hundreds.

Allegations of fraud at Hazon Yeshaya, a charity that claimed to feed Holocaust survivors, have probably not made it any easier to raise money.

Campaigns that focus on the poverty of survivors also create an image of them as charity cases, when, in reality, many of those who lived through the hell of the Shoah somehow found the strength to put all that behind them and embark on the daunting challenges that faced the fledgling Jewish state – fighting our many enemies, absorbing immigration and creating a society made up primarily of refugees and immigrants.

As Holocaust scholar Hanna Yablonka has pointed out, the vast majority of survivors who came to Israel focused on rebuilding their lives and building the new Jewish state – and they were wildly successful, worthy of being called heroes.

“Most survivors found a core of inner strength that is hard for us to comprehend,” noted Yablonka.

“Their collective story is one of personal and human victory.”

Holocaust survivors have left their mark in every field from building and construction to the IDF, industry, law and culture. They became prominent painters, graphic artists, poets, writers, dancers, actors, academics and cultural icons.

Indeed, it is impossible to imagine the State of Israel today without their many contributions.

It is essential that we do everything in our power to ensure that needy survivors’ live their last years on earth without want and in dignity. But we must not allow the image of the survivor as a charity case to dominate public discourse.

As the number of the survivors dwindles, there is another story to tell, a heroic one of overcoming the horrors of their past and the adversity of their current situation, providing an inspiration to us all.
           

יום שני, 16 באפריל 2012

Benefit of the doubt


The speed and zeal with which many jumped to indict Lt.-Col. Shalom Eisner, deputy commander of the Jordan Valley Brigade, was maddening.

Admittedly, the footage of Eisner bashing the face of a Danish national in his early 20s with the side of his M-16 rifle appeared to show him using gratuitous violence.

But “evidence”– no matter how incriminating – provided by the International Solidarity Movement (ISM) should have been treated with extreme suspicion. Dedicated commanders such as Eisner, who have served our country with distinction, should have been given the benefit of the doubt – at least until a thorough investigation is conducted.

Eisner, in particular, has in the past exhibited heroism during wartime and sensitivity toward the Palestinian population. During the Saluki battle in the Second Lebanon War, he led soldiers in battle and helped extract a tank crew under fire. About a year ago, he helped a Palestinian woman give birth after which the baby underwent life-saving procedures under his command.

The ISM, by contrast, has a history of high-intensity confrontations with IDF soldiers that have on occasion led to the death of its activists. One well-known example is the March 2003 case of Rachel Corrie who, according to an IDF investigation, was accidentally run over in Rafah, Gaza, by an IDF bulldozer uncovering an arms-smuggling tunnel.

ISM’s goal is to provoke IDF soldiers and capture on film the temporary lapse of a soldier such as Eisner – trained to fight wars on conventional and non-conventional battlefields – not to deal with crowd control and wage battles fought on YouTube and Twitter with trouble-making provocateurs from abroad and their ever-ready camera crews.

The ISM and other so-called “peace groups” choose to stage these provocations – often attended by European youths looking for action – in Israel, because they know that the risk of getting seriously hurt or killed is low.

Unlike most countries in the world, Israel’s security forces do everything humanly possible to use non-violent means to control unlawful demonstrations. In other places, ISM activists have been murdered. The case of Vittorio Arrigoni – abducted and executed by hanging in April 2011 by Salafists in the Gaza Strip – is one such example.

While the blow dealt by Eisner to the Danish activist as shown on the video clip broadcast on TV stations here and around the world was deplorable, its severity – which has more to do with international opinion and less to do with the well-being of the mildly injured activist – should not be blown out of proportion. The possibility cannot be ruled out that the video footage was tampered to make it appear that Eisner struck the Dane for no reason at all.

Unfortunately, our leaders were quick to jump to conclusions even before the IDF and police managed to get their hands on the original, unedited, video footage.

They seemed to think that we could gain points in the eyes of our enemies and critics – and the international media – by overreacting and pre-judging the case.

Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu declared: “Such behavior does not characterize IDF soldiers and officers, and has no place in the Israel Defense Forces and in the State of Israel.”

President Shimon Peres said he had been “shocked and disgusted” when he saw the videotape of Eisner striking the activist. And IDF Chief of Staff Benny Gantz called the incident “severe.”

The ease with which these leaders and others denounced Eisner conveys a mixed message to our soldiers.

Instead of providing them with the trust and backing they so desperately need when confronting radical activists bent on disrupting public order, our leaders issued hasty statements based on partial evidence. This sort of response will inevitably undermine IDF soldiers’ confidence in their next confrontation with anti-Israel activists.

The prime minister, the president and others who leveled criticism at Eisner should have refrained from commenting until the findings of a proper probe are released. It is the least that a man with Eisner’s merits deserves.

יום שלישי, 10 באפריל 2012

Serving together


It is no easy matter for the IDF to bring together soldiers from diverse backgrounds to cooperate for the common goal of defending the State of Israel.

Societal fault lines between religious and secular, right-wing and left-wing, Jewish and non-Jewish are very sensitive. With little provocation, disagreements can quickly devolve into serious confrontations and disrupt the sort of unity of purpose needed during military duty. Therefore, a willingness to compromise to find common ground is essential.

Adherence to Jewish law – Halacha – is an important aspect of the IDF’s day-to-day functioning, as it should be in a state that defines itself as Jewish. By providing them with prayer time and kosher food and by commemorating the Shabbat and holidays, the army enables religious soldiers to feel comfortable serving in alongside their secular fellows. Occasionally, however, creating this common ground can cause some inconveniences for secular soldiers.

That was the case on Passover eve – which fell last Shabbat – when a group of IDF soldiers, both religious and secular, were forced to eat cold food because of an IDF rabbi’s interpretation of Halacha.

Infantry soldiers from the Haruv Battalion – one of several battalions belonging to the Kfir Brigade, responsible for maintaining security in Judea and Samaria – returned to their army base from military activity late on Passover eve. After washing up and sitting down to read the Haggada and conduct the Seder, the soldiers were told that they would be served matza, salads and cold cuts, but no hot food. Apparently one of the cooks had desecrated Shabbat and Passover by connecting a hot plate after sundown to heat up food. Another cook noticed this and told the rabbi, who ruled that the food could not be eaten that day. Since IDF health regulations prohibit the refrigeration of food once it has been cooked and prepared for serving, all of the heated food had to be thrown out.

It could be that the rabbi was overzealous in his ruling.

According to many halachic authorities, desecration of the Shabbat by an irreligious Jew can be seen as unintentional. Under the circumstances, only an intentional desecration of the Shabbat would make it forbidden to eat the food.

Nevertheless, after the rabbi made his ruling, the brigade commander enforced it. All soldiers, both religious and secular, were obligated by IDF regulations to refrain from eating the food. Some of the soldiers complained to their parents. One mother told Army Radio that she could not understand how the brigade commander could allow his soldiers to “go starve” on Passover eve: “Rabbis are running things in the IDF.

The army has become haredi [ultra-Orthodox] and there is no rational decision-making.”

WHILE WE sympathize with the mother, the incident should not be blown out of proportion. The soldiers ate cold food; they did not starve. And while it appears that more media attention has been devoted in recent years to religious-related tensions in the IDF due to the sharp rise in the number of religious men serving, it is a gross exaggeration to suggest that rabbis are running the IDF. If anything, media attention to the Passover food incident has more to do with parents’ increasing willingness to interfere with the inner workings of the IDF.

Bringing together religious and secular Israelis in a military framework entails compromise on both sides.

Secular soldiers need to understand that enforcing kosher rules enables their religious fellows to serve with them.

But religious soldiers and their rabbis also have an obligation. They should do their best to find leniencies in Halacha where possible so that secular soldiers are not forced to endure unnecessary burdens.

Whether the issue is gender segregation, threats to refuse military orders to evacuate a settlement, or adherence to Shabbat, religious soldiers and their rabbis should embrace moderation, not religious extremism.

Military service is a cooperative endeavor of cardinal importance. Succeeding at this endeavor entails mutual compromise and sensitivity to the needs and desires of those who hold different views.