יום שלישי, 28 בפברואר 2012

Cut gas taxes

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=259797

On Wednesday night at midnight, gasoline prices will rise to record levels. A liter of 95 octane gas will climb about 30 agorot and cost about NIS 8, approximately double the price in the US and about the same level as in Germany, Italy and Norway.

Treasury officials say the rise in gas prices is a direct result of global trends. Should tensions explode between the West and Tehran over the Iranian regime’s push to develop nuclear weapons, say economists, oil supply could be disrupted. Anticipation of a sudden shortage has been driving prices up.

Despite claims by Treasury officials, however, international analysts are actually predicting that oil prices, which have dropped slightly in recent days, will continue to fall in the near future. As Israelis prepare for yet another gas price hike at home, it seems that there is an opposite trend worldwide. A report released recently by Capital Economics predicts that oil prices could fall as much as $10 a barrel.

Other factors that might drive down gas prices include release of emergency crude stock and the perception that Iran will not make good on its threat to block the Strait of Hormuz, through which one-fifth of the world’s oil tankers pass every day.

Though Treasury officials would like you to think otherwise, the price at the pump is only partly connected to global market trends. More than any other factor it is government policy that determines price disparities around the globe from Rome to Los Angeles, from Oslo to Cairo. In Latin American and Middle East nations, such as Venezuela and Saudi Arabia, oil is produced by government-owned companies and local gas prices are kept low as a benefit to citizens.

In contrast, in many European countries and in Israel, gas is heavily taxed.

In addition to the 16 percent value-added tax, we are forced to pay a NIS 2.96 excise tax on every liter of gasoline. The price of a liter of gasoline is further jacked up due to the fact that we pay VAT not just on the gas but also on the excise tax. This redundant taxation – an indirect tax on an indirect tax – adds nearly half a shekel to each liter of gasoline. And this is a regressive tax, since both rich and poor own cars or use public transportation that will also be affected by the price rise.

MK Meir Sheetrit (Kadima) has drafted a bill – slated to come up for a vote Wednesday in the Knesset – that would do away with this redundant tax. In parallel, Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu has asked the director-general of the Prime Minister’s office, Harel Locker, a former tax attorney, to look into alternatives that would lower gas prices. And MK Carmel Shama-Cohen (Likud), chairman of the Knesset Economics Committee, has drafted a bill to be presented Wednesday that calls for temporary cuts in VAT when gas prices climb above NIS 6.6 per liter.

But Treasury officials are warning that gas taxes must not be touched. Every 10 agorot tax reduction will result in a state revenue shortfall of NIS 700 million a year, they say. And gas tax revenues are already expected to fall as a result of the higher gas prices that cause people to use their cars less. Besides, according to Doron Cohen, the temporary director-general of the Treasury, the Finance Ministry has already agreed to a NIS 2.5 billion decrease in gas tax revenues as part of the Trajtenberg Committee recommendations.

Cohen was referring to the cancellation of a planned excise tax hike. The hike was recommended by Bank of Israel economists in a 2010 report as a means of reducing pollution by discouraging Israelis from driving too much. Cohen said that instead of cutting gas taxes, which would force the government to cut the budgets of various ministries, citizens should buy more fuel efficient cars and drive less.

We agree that for the sake of pollution reduction and energy conservation, it would be advisable for Israelis to drive less and use more fuel efficient cars.

However, we do not believe that the state should be using taxation to coercively reeducate its citizens.

And if a tax cut results in lower state revenues, so be it; the gas tax should never have been charged in the first place.

יום שני, 27 בפברואר 2012

Begin's legacy

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=259663

On the 20th anniversary of Menachem Begin’s death, many are revisiting the former prime minister’s important legacy.

Perhaps the most significant aspect of Begin’s political leadership was his unique ability to bridge the gap between ideological purity and political realism, an important component of his ultimate political success.

It was in large part due to Begin’s pragmatism and moderation that violence was avoided immediately after the establishment of the State of Israel.

On June 6, 1948, the Hagana, under orders from David Ben-Gurion, fired upon and sank the Altalena, an arms ship belonging to the Irgun, the Revisionist Movement’s military arm headed by Begin. If not for Begin’s responsible leadership, the situation could easily have spiraled out of control and led to more bloodshed.

But Begin, essentially bowing to Ben-Gurion’s will and preferring compromise and moderation over stubborn pride, vowed there would be no civil war among Jews.

Throughout his long years in the opposition, Begin resolved to keep Herut, the party he formed with the establishment of the state, in the political mainstream.

To do so, he worked toward, and eventually succeeded in, moderating and incorporating some of the ideological purists of the Revisionist Movement and the Lehi (Freedom Fighters for Israel), or Stern Group, into Herut.

In 1965, Begin orchestrated an alignment with the centrist Liberal party to form Gahal (Herut-Liberal Bloc), which garnered 26 mandates in that year’s election.

It was the entry of Gahal into the Labor-led national-unity government just before the outbreak of the Six Day War that permanently freed Begin from his political isolation.

But while Begin exercised political sagacity, he continued to hold to strong ideological principles, such as the belief in keeping the whole Land of Israel, particular Judea and Samaria. In August 1970, he quit the government headed by Golda Meir to protest initial acceptance of the Rogers Plan, which included a ceasefire agreement with Egypt along the Suez Canal and would have brought the Soviet Union into peace negotiations on the side of the Arabs. Begin said he opposed the government’s formal acceptance of UN Security Council Resolution 242, which is based on “peace for withdrawal,” including in Judea and Samaria.

After the devastating Yom Kippur War, with the Labor Party’s hegemony increasingly called into question, Begin joined forces with Ariel Sharon to mastermind the birth of the Likud out of Gahal and several smaller factions. His political savvy was vindicated in 1977 with the Likud’s electoral upset, overturning Labor’s decades-long monopoly on power.

Immediately upon entering office, Begin sent out signals to his Arab neighbors that he was prepared to enter into a peace agreement. Anwar Sadat, the Egyptian president, apparently sensed that Begin was a strong ruler capable of making peace, and answered his overtures. Misnamed the Sadat initiative, the resulting 1979 Peace Treaty was in reality a product of Begin’s push for peace.

Perhaps Begin’s unique ability to bridge the gap between ideological purity and political realism can be attributed to his liberal ideological roots. Like his mentor, Ze’ev Jabotinsky, Begin believed strongly in maintaining a robust liberal democracy that protected free speech and the human rights of both Jews and non- Jews. As far back as 1956, Begin demanded that the Knesset “not legislate any law that limits freedom of expression, orally or in writing.”

He strongly opposed Emergency Defense Regulations dating back to the British Mandate, which severely restricted Arab Israelis’ basic freedoms in the decades after the War of Independence. He also pushed for a strong and independent Supreme Court – though he never supported judicial activism. And he was instrumental in facilitating the appointment of the nation’s first Arab Supreme Court Justice. Begin’s readiness to champion the rights of minorities was probably bolstered by his experiences as a Jew living in Poland between the two world wars and later as a Zionist activist in Palestine under British rule.

Begin’s unique combination of political pragmatism and moderation are an important legacy. We can only hope that our contemporary politicians learn from his example.
       

יום ראשון, 26 בפברואר 2012

Grunis's restraint

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=259504

Justice Dorit Beinisch will be stepping down Tuesday as Supreme Court president at the age of 70. Does this mark the end of an era of judicial activism begun by her predecessor and mentor, former president Aharon Barak? Undoubtedly, incoming president Justice Asher Grunis favors more judicial restraint than his predecessors Barak and Beinisch.

In a number of rulings, Grunis has shown an aversion to judicial activism. Just last week, Grunis dissented from the High Court of Justice’s majority decision against extending the Tal Law, which legislated exemptions from military service.

Grunis, in a lone opinion, held that the court had no business interfering with an issue that should be left up to democratically elected lawmakers. Part of Grunis’s reasoning was practical. The incoming president rightly argued that the highly volatile issue of haredi draft-dodging, which has sparked heated debate for decades, would not be solved by a single court ruling. But Grunis also based his decision on the more fundamental belief that the court should limit judicial review of legislation to a minimum.

Grunis used the same sort of judicial restraint in additional cases such as in last week’s High Court decision not to strike down the Disengagement Pardons Law, which exonerates right-wing activists from all but the most violent crimes perpetrated during demonstrations against the dismantling of settlements in the Gaza Strip and northern Samaria.

In January, Grunis ruled in favor of upholding the Citizenship and Entry Law, which restricts the right of Palestinians married to Israelis receiving Israeli citizenship. In both these cases, Grunis shared the majority opinion.

Grunis is also in favor of doing away with a legal innovation first initiated by Aharon Barak in the mid-1980s when Meir Shamgar served as Supreme Court president. In Barak’s creative jurisprudence, any citizen may ask the court to block action by the government even if the citizen is not personally affected by it and therefore lacks “standing.”

Allowing anyone to preoccupy the court with frivolous petitions “which must be addressed posthaste,” wrote Grunis in a May 2011 decision that rejected a request to disqualify a recipient of the Israel Prize, “robs the court of valuable time and forces it to put on hold scheduled cases which ought to be accorded priority.”

In large part due to the fact that almost anyone can petition almost anything, the High Court has been flooded with petitions. Approximately 10,000 petitions are brought before the court every year, about half of which are discussed. For the sake of comparison, the US Supreme Court – which serves primarily as an appeals court and restricts itself to hearing only petitions from individuals with “standing” – deals with about 80 cases a year.

It is not immediately clear what kind of influence Grunis will have on the Supreme Court’s rulings in the future. His ability to hand-pick panels of judges to deal with particularly sensitive cases is limited. Court tradition dictates that a judge’s seniority, not his or her opinions, decides the formation of panels – whether these be the typical three-judge panels or expanded panels chosen to deal with more contentious cases.

But if Grunis does manage to have an impact, say by virtue of his personal leadership qualities, we believe it would be a positive development. By exercising judicial restraint and by restricting the right to petition the court to those with “standing,” Grunis might succeed in alleviating the court’s heavy work load, thus speeding the judicial process. Also, by recognizing that not everything can be ruled upon judicially, the Supreme Court will force our lawmakers to deal with the most controversial issues and make the decisions they were voted into office to make.

There will always be a need for judicial review. Tolerance, pluralism and respect for minority rights must continue to be protected by the Supreme Court. There is always a danger that a “tyranny of the majority” will trample the rights of those who are not properly represented in our political system.

But the Supreme Court’s strength and legitimacy is best protected when exercised with restraint and when judges are not perceived as partisan or politically motivated. Grunis’s moderate approach will best ensure that the court remains a respected and honored institution.

יום חמישי, 23 בפברואר 2012

Change without coercion

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=259182

In the wake of the Tal Law’s demise, Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu faces tough choices. He could try to patch together yet another ad hoc Tal Law-like arrangement with the haredi parties that would maintain, with a few cosmetic changes, the present “status quo” that enables 60,000-plus draft-age haredi men to skirt military service.

Doing so would place him in direct confrontation with Israel Beiteinu chairman Avigdor Liberman, who has already said publicly that he will not tolerate any more stopgap arrangements with the ultra-Orthodox and that the time has come to settle the issue of haredi draft-dodging once and for all.

Appeasing the haredim would also hurt Netanyahu’s popularity among many Israelis who are rightly convinced that the present situation is, as Bank of Israel Gov. Stanley Fischer pointed out last year, “unsustainable.”

Over half of haredi families live under the poverty line, since haredi men cannot legally work as long as they indefinitely postpone mandatory military service to devote themselves to Torah study. This creates an increasingly draining burden on those Israelis who are productive and support the welfare state.

According to a 2007 Bank of Israel study, 70 percent of ultra-Orthodox men were neither employed nor actively seeking employment. Haredi draft-dodging is also undermining the “people’s army ethos” that posits that all able-bodied men should take part in the defense of the country. About a quarter of all 18-year-old Jewish men do not enlist in the IDF, over half of whom are haredi. In 2011, 72.5% of 18-years-old Tel Avivians were drafted. In Bnei Brak, 12.6% were.

Alternatively, Netanyahu could opt to draft legislation opposed by Shas and United Torah Judaism – the two haredi coalition partners – that would put significant pressure on haredim to enlist in the IDF or perform some other form of national service. This might appease Liberman’s Israel Beiteinu and the grassroots movements pushing for a more equal sharing of the military burden. But it would also precipitate the collapse of the government coalition.

The haredi parties – faced with the prospect of the forced draft of tens of thousands of yeshiva students – would likely leave the government. Rabbi Elazar Menachem Man Shach, the unrivaled leader of haredi Jewry in Israel who passed away in 2001, declared that it was better to emigrate than to be drafted into the IDF. Without the haredi parties, the prime minister would have no choice but to call early elections.

Haredi politicians would undoubtedly see the electoral potential in fostering feelings of victimization and religious persecution. Netanyahu might also be tempted to take the route of coercion.

Taking a strong stand against the haredim might increase Netanyahu’s popularity, take away voters from Israel Beiteinu and preempt Yair Lapid and Kadima who are likely to run on campaigns calling to draft the ultra-Orthodox. However, though we empathize with the desire to force haredim to accept a more equitable share of national responsibility, it would be unwise and counterproductive to use coercion.

In nearly every realm of their lives, haredim are undergoing rapid changes, despite the opposition of official haredi leadership.

From colleges that cater exclusively to the haredi population that are producing haredi lawyers, accountants, social workers, computer programmers and psychologists, to widespread Internet use. An entire genre of fiction, including science fiction, written by haredim for haredim has developed and popular haredi parental guidance literature, influenced by Western psychology, now advises parents to replace strict hierarchical relationships between parents and children with a more democratic, liberal-minded approach as a means of stemming defections among haredi youths.

The best way of retarding this process of integration – which includes a growing number of haredi men who are enlisting in the IDF – would be to launch an offensive against the haredi community. Integration is an evolutionary process that can be nurtured, even encouraged, but that cannot be forced.

יום שלישי, 21 בפברואר 2012

Consumer power

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=258657

Yoav Rokach-Penn probably did not imagine he would breathe new life into the grassroots consumer uprising first launched this summer. But that is precisely what he did when he walked into his local Shop Rite in New Jersey, took a picture of an Israeli-made candy bar, and posted it on his Facebook juxtaposed with a picture of the price-tag for the identical candy bar in Israel.

The price for Elite-Strauss’s Pesek Zman candy bar in New Jersey was just 74 cents (including taxes) compared to NIS 6.29 (about $1.70) in Israel. Rokach-Penn’s Facebook picture quickly went viral over the weekend.

On Saturday evening, in a feeble and somewhat disingenuous attempt to defuse the situation, Elite-Strauss’s PR people posted a message on the firm’s Facebook page citing the high cost of living in Israel as justification for the higher prices charged here. Fuel is more expensive in Israel, claimed Strauss, as are housing, transportation, production costs and taxes.

But consumers were not buying Elite-Strauss’s lame excuse and the market was unforgiving. On Sunday Strauss’s shares dropped 3.5%, representing a NIS 170 million decrease in market capitalization in active trading.

Unfortunately, candy bars, a product we can all easily do without, is not the only food item that is significantly more expensive in Israel than most places in the world.

Food prices in Israel in 2008 were 15 percent higher than the average for OECD countries, according to a Bank of Israel study released a month ago. And in the years since the situation has probably gotten worse by about ten percent, estimated Bank of Israel economists.

Some of the reasons for our ridiculously high prices are obvious and eminently solvable. For instance, it is widely known that the milk, fresh meat and fish markets are protected from foreign competition by high tariffs (there is a 150% tax on imported milk and butter) combined with cartel-like price fixing inside Israel.

This government has taken steps in the right direction.

Finance Minister Yuval Steinitz signed a directive December abolishing customs duties on hundreds of imports.

The changes, recommended by the Trajtenberg Committee, created in response to this summer’s demonstrations, went into effect on January 1 and are expected to cost the government more than $100 million annually in lost revenue while saving consumers that same amount.

But counterproductive steps have been taken as well.

Last March, the Netanyahu government, usually so strongly pro-free market, passed the Law for the Planning of the Dairy Market. In the 50-0 vote, the Knesset approved legislation reminiscent of now-defunct centrally- planned economies. Instead of allowing free market forces to sort out supply and demand in the dairy market, a special “quota committee” would determine annual dairy output. Though the law gives the Industry, Trade and Employment minister the prerogative to open up the local dairy market to international competition, Shalom Simhon, the present minister who is seen as representing the interests of moshavim (many of which are major producers of milk), has said publicly that doing so would be ineffective and would take too long.

The olive oil and honey markets are governed by a similar combination of price collusion and protection from foreign competition via tariffs. For instance, a study published by the Jerusalem Institute for Market Studies showed that due to tariffs and price collusion an average one-liter bottle of olive oil, at NIS 17, costs three times more in Israel than it does in Spain and Greece.

Other factors contribute to high food prices, such as the strong demand for kosher products, which makes it more difficult for non-kosher imports to compete.

Israelis also seem to be more willing than their foreign counterparts to pay more for imported brand-name products.

This might be because Israelis attach more importance to brands or because they have become accustomed to paying exorbitant prices for staple products.

But the tide is turning. People like Rokach-Penn or Itzik Elrov, the haredi man from Bnei Brak who launched the Great Israeli Cottage Cheese Uprising via Facebook in June or a group of retired men and women based in Even Yehuda called the Club for Smart Consumerism who monitor and publicize prices charged by local supermarkets are developing a more informed and mature consumer culture.

Our society is fed up with the sort of price gouging perpetrated by a host of food manufacturers, brand-name importers, and various other opportunists. Business people who fail to note the sea change taking place in Israeli society and change their greedy ways will be punished by a new generation of enlightened consumers.

The drop in Strauss’s share price is just a taste of the potential influence an angry and mobilized consumer populace can wield.

The status quo

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=258813

Halting public transportation from sundown Friday until Saturday would be considered a deviation from what is known as “the status quo.” A modus vivendi between religious and secular, the status quo, which dates from the pre-state era, essentially set down the limits for religious encroachment into civil and public life in the fledgling Jewish state.

Marriage and divorce in accordance with Halacha, the serving of kosher food in all state institutions, the establishment of state-funded religious education and the exemption of women – and a small, elite group of male Torah scholars – from military service are all included in what is loosely referred to as the status quo.

Many mistakenly believe that the status quo is the result of haredi political extortion. According to this false narrative, the haredim threatened to join forces with anti-Zionist British foreign secretary Ernest Bevin against the creation of Israel unless David Ben-Gurion and other leaders of the Yishuv caved in to their demands for a “more Jewish” state.

In reality, as sociologist Menachem Friedman has shown, the status quo is the result of a mutual understanding among the secular Zionist leadership and haredi rabbis and politicians that finding a means of coexistence was essential to fostering the unity and social cohesion needing to meet the many challenges facing Israel, from fighting the War of Independence and absorbing hundreds of thousands of immigrants to building the first Jewish sovereignty in nearly two millennia.

Still, initiatives are launched from time to time to change the status quo, which technically dates back to a June 1947 letter written by Ben-Gurion to Yitzhak Meir Levin and other leaders of Agudat Israel promising “consideration” for religious sensibilities. The most recent example was a decision Monday by the Tel Aviv City Council to ask the Transportation Ministry for permission to operate public transportation in the metropolis on Shabbat.

Tamar Zandberg, the Meretz councilwoman who proposed the motion – passed in a 13-7 vote and supported by Mayor Ron Huldai – argued: “It is unacceptable to continue living in accordance with an arrangement dating back over 60 years that determines such a significant part of our lifestyle.”

Indeed, cogent arguments can be made in favor of permitting public transportation in Tel Aviv, a predominantly secular place with a unique cultural character setting it apart from other cities. Since before the establishment of the state, Haifa and Nazareth – including Upper Nazareth – have operated public transportation due to their large Arab populations. The same is true for Eilat, probably due to its tourism town character and the fact that it is isolated from the rest of Israel. Similarly, the “Tel Aviv bubble” is unique for its consciously secular orientation and its high proportion of foreign workers and migrants.

If a poll were conducted, the vast majority of Tel Aviv’s residents would probably vote in favor of public transportation on Shabbat. A nationwide poll conducted in 2010 by the Smith Institute for Hiddush, an organization fighting for separation of state and religion, found that 63 percent of Israelis favored public transportation on Shabbat, including 93% of secular Israelis.

Nevertheless, permitting public transportation in Tel Aviv – dubbed “the first Hebrew city” – would mark a deviation from tradition as enshrined in the status quo.

Should a simple vote be enough to do away with a longstanding tradition of keeping Shabbat in the public sphere? Should even Tel Aviv – a cosmopolitan bastion of secularism considered to be the best gay travel destination in the world – abandon that modicum of Jewishness that only serves to accentuate its eclectic uniqueness? How much do Tel Aviv’s residents truly suffer due to a lack of public transportation on Shabbat? Is alleviating this suffering worth doing away with a cultural and religious fixture?

Unfortunately, it is unlikely that a soul-searching public discussion of these issues and others – such as the environmental benefits of halting public transportation one day a week – will ever take place.

In part, this is because Transportation Minister Yisrael Katz has quashed debate by announcing that he would veto the Tel Aviv City Council’s initiative, effectively using coercion to protect the status quo. Public discourse on such issues tends to be so polarized that true dialogue is impossible. We can only hope that the day will come when a truly free and open debate – and reevaluation – of the status quo will be possible.

יום ראשון, 19 בפברואר 2012

Fighting the apartheid libel

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Editorials/Article.aspx?id=258507

In 2005, the first year college students organized to compare the situation in Judea and Samaria to South African apartheid, events were restricted to the University of Toronto.

By 2006, the hate-fest had spread to Montreal and Oxford. In 2007, it grew to eight cities; in 2008, to 24; in 2009, to 38; in 2010, to over 40; and last year to 55 cities.

This year, Israeli Apartheid Week (IAW) – from February 20 to March 11 – will be “celebrated” in even more cities worldwide, from Europe and South Africa to the Middle East and North America.

What is the best way of combating this worrying spread of the apartheid libel, which historian Robert Wistrich has noted in his book, A Lethal Obsession: Anti-Semitism from Antiquity to the Global Jihad, has its intellectual roots in Soviet propaganda? One of the answers has been provided by the Public Diplomacy Ministry. Some 100 Israelis from diverse backgrounds – Ethiopian immigrants, Arabs, homosexuals, settlers, security experts and artists – will fan out on college campuses across the globe during IAW. Having undergone weeks of training by the ministry, the envoys – chosen to show that Israel has a multicultural society that values equality and human rights – will fight what Public Diplomacy Minister Yuli Edelstein calls the “disease” of ignorance.

However, while we wish the envoys much success, experts at fighting anti-Israel sentiment on college campuses have learned that the best defense is a strong offense. The natural tendency when confronted with rabid Israel-bashing is to respond immediately, set the record straight, refute inaccuracies and confront boycotts, divestment and sanctions (BDS) supporters.

But by allowing Israel’s detractors to frame the discussion, pro-Israel activists run the risk of losing their efficacy. Instead of trying to convince IAW participants of their errors, picketing their activities or clashing directly in any other way, the best tactic may be to be proactive.

Pro-Israel students at the University of Pennsylvania provided a good example of how to effectively combat Israel bashing. When anti-Israel activists on campus held a national BDS conference earlier this month, pro-Israel organizers chose not to confront the BDS supporters, but not to ignore them either.

A wide range of programs, activities and outreach efforts targeted groups both small and large within the campus community that were ready to listen. Israel Peace Week, which is in its third year, is another initiative that refrains from direct confrontation with Israel-bashers while putting forward its own agenda.

Still, pro-Israel activities on campus – such as Israel Peace Week or the University of Pennsylvania initiative – should be part of a year-round effort.

Burning Campus? Rethinking Israel Advocacy at America’s Universities and Colleges, a 48-page document recently published by The David Project, represents perhaps the first concerted effort to combat anti-Israel sentiment and activities on US campuses.

One of the central recommendations made in the document, also known as the “White Paper,” is an emphasis on the importance of reaching out to student groups of all kinds – including African-American, Latino and American- Indian – throughout the year.

It is too late to launch into action when IAW rolls around.

Rather, ties need to be nurtured throughout the year. When a BDS conference or some other anti-Israel activity hits a campus, pro-Israel activists should already be well-positioned to rally support.

Other tips mentioned in the White Paper include realizing the futility of reaching out to students and faculty in the humanities and social science departments – often a hotbed of extreme left-wing ideology inimical to Israel.

In contrast, students and faculty in the business and science departments tend to be more willing to listen. Also, special effort should be made to focus on “influencers” – the college newspaper editors, student government leaders and dominant fraternity and sorority members – who can help make a wider impact.

It is important never to forget that many of the activists behind IAW and BDS are not interested in simply “reforming” Israel. As Norman Finkelstein made clear recently at Imperial College, London, leaders of the BDS movement “think they are really clever” by covering up their real intentions when they call for a “three-tier” agenda of ending the occupation, demanding the right of return for all Palestinian refugees and equal rights for all Arabs in Israel. “You know and I know what the result is. There is no Israel!” he said.